At first, I was trying hard to represent this theme with
positive frame. But it is kind of difficult because this dance is about war,
about fight, about anger, about frightening theme. And it is not the only war
theme dance in Indonesia, we also have other war dance, Mandau Dance in
Kalimantan, Caci Dance from East Nusa Tenggara, and other war dance from Nias,
Papua, and Aceh (Prang Sabil Dance), It spread across the archipelago.
So I started to do little internet research on how people tried
to describe and explain these dances in positive perspective. It is various and
interesting in the way people framing the story of the dance. They come across
many philosophies, and it is not necessarily the original one. For example, in
one blog, they say, CAKALELE war dance that is often performed in front an
honor guest, is a way of saying that the guest should be no worries about
his/her/their safety, because the host which is represent by the dancer is good
warrior and they will guarantee their safety. In another blog, people interprets
war dance as a dance that show a power
and courage of local people that shown by their skill in using weapon, another
said that the war dance is about knight spirit and heroism. I think we try hard
to make the narrative positively compelling.
But I just thinking, HOW IF, these dances are truly about
war, about fight, about blood, about trying to conquer any enemy or new pieces
of land, or about being superior from others which is really relevant if we put
this matter in to context (time and situation when this dance initially created).
This idea challenges the whole concept of my August drawing and narrative project
which initially about promoting Indonesia culture through positive
interpretation. For example, how if, I hardly think of any good justification
of one particular culture, such as cockfighting or bull fighting which has
problem to deal with animal rights issue. Is it completely bad cultures? How If
I suddenly I got an idea to frame it like this ‘When watching bull fighting or
cockfighting, people do interact each other, this event became platform of social
interaction of community’? Does it make any different?
So, this makes me realize that human can always interpret
the cultures in the different way. It is not necessarily right or wrong. This
is about framing, it is about perspective, and this makes our culture more
vibrant and continuously alive.